10-11-15, 10:46 AM | |
Join Date: Mar 2002
|
Thanks Ladies!
I really appreciate the advice (both good & bad). I'm going to start it the week of Oct 18 and see what happens. I like that most of you saw a shrinkage in your clothing size. This is a goal of mine but really a fringe benefit. I just want to feel strong and be a bit leaner. Lesia |
10-12-15, 10:26 AM | |
Join Date: Jun 2004
|
This thread interests me I just started lifting heavy again with body beast and I love it. It's made me think of redoing an sts rotation. I've gotten great results from body beast. My results from sts weren't great and here's what I think the difference is: SPEED. Sagi moves at a clip in all of the workouts. I'm soaked and spent and my heart rate is sky high for mostly the whole workout every workout in body beast. Sts is so slow. I don't remember sweating or getting any cardio from it at all.
I'd love to hear other's thoughts. |
10-12-15, 10:39 AM | |
VF Supporter
Join Date: Oct 2006
|
I have done STS all the way through once. I did not see significant gains in my fitness, either strength or size of muscle mass. I'm not a newbie by any means, and I did have significant musculature to start--genetics has blessed me with the ability to build muscle quickly.
My issue, and I'm aware that it is MY issue, is that my appetite gets crazy when I dive into any intense weight program like STS. I admit that I simply do not have the willpower to keep my diet under control when I do heavy weight workouts, and I've pretty much sworn off of them. I was so disappointed at the end of STS since I was hoping this program would help me lean out and build strength, but not so in my case--probably a direct result of my diet dilemma. YMMV. |
10-12-15, 11:55 AM | |
Join Date: May 2006
|
I've done both Body Beast and STS (recently added Edge Booty ) as my main strength rotations over the years. I get my best results (see above) with STS but only if I'm I using it by design. Meaning that it was developed to help you lift progressively heavier. So doing the typical 3,5 & 8lb weights might be fun but it won't take advantage of the program's unique benefits. I used the 1 rep max and Cathe's website to calculate/print out my weight selections/goal for that day's workout. This is what really set the program apart for me. For example, I started using 20-25lbs for unilateral lat rows but ended using a 50lb dumbbell. So no matter where you start as an individual, you're basically competing with yourself to continually advance your strength. The fact that it happens on a micro level (I actually only added 1/2 lb plates to my dumbbells/bar at times) is what makes it possible to move forward. Going with the standard weight selections (for example, the leap from a 15 to a 20lb weight) can be too much so it's easy to get "trapped" at the lower weight unless you microload. I ended up picking up a lot of used plates/dumbbells at Play It Again Sports so that I could keep up with the program's suggested weight selections.
I can get away with lower weights on Body Beast because he moves at a clip. But I don't get as good as results. Still, it's an excellent program and provides variety and adequate maintenance for me. I'm loving Edge Booty and have high hopes as I get to know the program. Obviously, nutrition always pays a role in results and I think you have to experiment to see what works for your body. I DO NOT benefit from adding extra calories or protein when doing these heavy weight programs. I would only do that if my goal was to increase my size or bulk. My strength gains are excellent without added calories and my muscle definition is greatly improved if I don't protein/calorie load.
__________________
Taiga |
10-12-15, 01:30 PM | ||
Join Date: Aug 2013
|
Body beast versus STS - speed
Quote:
I shall remember your post and eventually get back to this thread to report my view comparing both. Thanks for sharing your thoughts |
|
10-12-15, 02:19 PM | |
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: New Jersey
|
Heavy and/or very intense programs typically cause my appetite to decrease drastically. I think that may be why it was harder for me to see much aesthetic gains with STS. I know the strength was there, but my muscles just don't pop. However, I saw great strength, endurance, and aesthetic gains with Xtrain. My body may do better with mixing it up constantly. I really did enjoy the strength gains with STS though.
__________________
"You humans have the potential to be the most wonderful beings there are - if you can get past all these enormous stupid spots you seem to have in your hearts. It's not your fault. You just don't know how to work your hearts right yet. That's why there are dogs." - Jim Butcher, Zoo Day |
10-12-15, 05:35 PM | |
Join Date: Mar 2002
|
I just started STS today with Mesocycle 1 Disc 1 Chest Shoulders & Biceps
Whoa! There are many different versions of pushups but because I'm struggling with pushups, I just chose to do regular pushups and concentrating on great form. Believe me regular pushups slay me anyway. What I found surprising is the sweat factor. Who knew that a weight workout would cause a sweat pool. Workout 1? Grade A Lesia |
Tags |
door anchor, dumbbell size, sts, sts results, weighted gloves |
|
|