I did the second Arms/Shoulders workout today. She messes up the counts significantly. Production should have worked for that to not be in the final product. Now I wonder if she messed up counts for Days 2 and 3 but I didn't notice. The Chest/Back workout is less than 10 minutes long, so maybe when I see it at normal speed I'll be able to tell if it is messed up from what was intended.
For Arms/Shoulders II, at the end she said this was Day 6. The rotation does intentionally go:
- Day 2 Arms/Shldrs
- Day 3 Legs/Butt
- Day 5 Legs/Butt
- Day 6 Arms/Shldrs
- Day 7 Chest/Back
I love everything she says and how she says it. I love that her goal is to "get beginners moving in the right direction" and "help them get their bodies ready to start getting fit". (These are not the exact quotes.)
If I were production, I would have done several tweaks. One example: I would have asked her to do longer cardio such as maybe at least 6 minutes instead of less than 2. The modifier barely moves, so I don't think 6 minutes would have scared many away. I also would have asked her to give a lot more form pointers because her audience might be completely clueless. Even though she didn't consult with me on how to do this DVD (LOL), I think it can get somebody normally glued to the couch to say, "Hey. Maybe I can do this with her. Maybe it will be kind of fun and maybe it won't kill me." This couch-potato can then start to train his/her brain to get moving, and the daily but very small volume of core work I think will really move the couch potato towards "getting that body ready to work on fitness" (again not an exact quote).
She does a yelling/foot-stomping thing that can be a deal breaker for plenty of people. It is neutral to me. I forced myself to stop having deal breakers like that when I really liked the JCore workouts but Jay himself drove me nuts with his non-stop talking. I finally told myself, "This person is a real human being in the real world. He has friends and family that love him. His training style is what he has chosen, and he doesn't choose his style to please me."
Now that I've done the sort-of-messed up second Arms/Shldrs, I think the only workout values for a person who already exercises might be:
- Motivation for times when the exerciser has gotten into a slump. (unless there are deal breakers: the yelling/foot-stomping thing, the acutal work that is done)
- Arms/Shldrs, the first one, might be good to train the brain on slow and heavy. She doesn't go heavy but she does go slowish. There are only 2 sets of 8 rather than the 4 or 5 sets pushed by my live class trainer. Doing only 2 sets might ease that beginning "Oh My! These feel so heavy to my hands!!!" A beginner to "heavy" might actually choose the right heavy instead of babying it a bit due to fear and hand discomfort.