Project: You - Pilates CoreKathy Smith
Year Released: 2005
Categories: Pilates/Core Strength
Video Fitness reviews may not be copied, quoted, or posted elsewhere without the permission of the reviewer
This is the core-focused pilates workout included in the Beachbody Project: You, Type 2 system which was intended for those with type 2 diabetes and generally geared towards beginners. I loved the simplicity of the yoga workout and reach for it often, so thought I would check out this pilates workout, even though I already have a lot of favorite pilates workouts, mostly from the 10 Minute Solution series. The DVD cover said this was a 20 minute workout but the Beachbody timer stated it was more like 17 minutes, which did not include Kathy’s instruction on core engagement at the beginning.
The first 10 minutes or so were focused on a prone position ab focused series: the hundred, roll up, and (!) roll over included in the warm up, followed by single and double leg stretch, the corkscrew, double leg stretch, scissors, and criss-cross. Lots of ab work here which had my abs burning! There was also rolling like a ball, and some brief plank work (both regular plank and reverse plank), and some spinal erector work in the remaining 7 minutes. The workout ends with the can-can then a mermaid stretch. I think she should have included a cobra stretch as well.
While I appreciated the challenging set, I hardly think, like others have mentioned, that it was beginner appropriate. Seriously? But for somebody more experienced in pilates, this was a welcome addition. Kathy made some creative visuals for your form like “the house for the mouse” which was to draw your abs up off the floor by tightening your muscles so a mouse could live under there, then later, so a whole family of mice could live under there. LOL! Like all Beachbody productions, this was high quality and I appreciated the countdown timer. For an as advertised beginner pilates workout, I would have to grade this a C- because a roll over in the warm up would make any beginner injured, but for a good pilates routine for those more experienced I would grade it an A-. I am likely to add this pilates workout to my regular routine to tighten my abs and core.
Kathy Smith is more businesslike and tuned down (read: not as hyper) as she is in some of her later videos, like Matrix Sculpt in which she is crazy bubbly (LOL). She does not demonstrate the moves but has three girls in which she points out form and modifications. I like Kathy a lot (both retro videos and newer ones) and think she’s a great instructor.
This workout was okay but, although it does show beginner modifications, I don't think they were beginner enough. Really, I've seen better. Ana Caban shows much better modifications than this. And this is supposed to be a workout series for beginners!
Typical chatty Kathy.
Note: This is a review of the FREE DVD which came in a package of Perdue Chicken Short Cuts. I *believe* that it is the same workout sold by Beach Body--the DVD is labelled "core/flex: Pilates Core"--but I'm not 100% sure.
This is a somewhat odd little Pilates workout. On the one hand, it initially appears to be designed for beginners--Kathy spends several minutes reviewing basic Pilates principles prior to the start of the workout--but on the other, it seems to be more appropriate for experienced Pilates practitioners, as Kathy's instruction is not overly detailed, and some more intermediate/advanced Pilates exercises are included.
Kathy does not perform the moves herself; rather, she leads three other exercisers, one of whom shows modifications and one of whom sometimes incorporates more advanced versions. The workout begins with traditional Pilates sequencing, starting with the hundred, the roll-up, and then the roll-over, a more intermediate/advanced move. Other basic Pilates moves included are rolling like a ball, the series of five, and swimming; additional intermediate/advanced moves included hip circles, leg pull-downs, and leg pull-ups. Kathy also adds a move I've never seen before, upper body circles, but she does not do any of the side kick series. The practice ends with the mermaid stretch.
I've seen this workout reported as being both 20 mintues and 25 minutes; minus Kathy's initial instruction, I clocked it at about 22-23 minutes. If you are looking for a short, moderate-paced, basic Pilates mat workout that includes a few more challenging moves, you will probably enjoy this. However, I definitely would NOT recommend this workout for those who are brand-new to Pilates.
I generally like Kathy, although sometimes she can be a bit too over-the-top for my liking. She was fine here though, giving good breath and other Pilates technique reminders as well as frequently using her background exercisers to provide comments on form.
About me: I'm an intermediate to low-advanced Pilates lover with many videos; I also take Stott and classical mat classes.
I really wasn't expecting much from Pilates Core and Yoga Flex, the two flexibility add-ons to the Project: YOU system. Pilates Core surprised me by being a somewhat well rounded, if brief, Pilates mat workout. Kathy instructs while her background exercisers perform. One is a designated modifier.
The routine starts off with a well-done tutorial on Pilates breathing and abdominal, rib cage and gluteal control. The 18 minute workout kicks in with one of the nicer renditions of the 100 I've done (i.e., over fast!). Rollup, Rollover, Ball, and Single Leg Circles segue right into Series of Five nicely. After that it gets a little dicey with moves I consider too hard for the rank beginner: Corkscrew, Can Can, Leg Pulldown among others. Rollover is an intermediate and potentially dangerous move and newbies need to develop more core strength before attempting it. I wish Kathy didn't throw it at customers trying their first Pilates workout.
Some 'uniquities' in this workout include upper body circles after the Corksrew - sort of a revolving crunch - and Kathy's visualization cue of "House for Mouse." As you lie prone on the mat, you imagine a mouse under your abdominal wall and pull it back far enough so that you don't crush the mouse. I prefer my Stott teacher's cue to "pick up a marble with your navel."
There is no Side Leg Series. I would have given this video a higher grade if the questionable moves were replaced with a well-rounded side series. It would also make the workout fall into better step with the whole Project: YOU theme.
What increases my score from a potential D+ to a C+ is that the workout flows well with no hang-time, it's over in 18 minutes and the music is nice. I would have raised it to B- if the modifier was better utilized for the iffy exercises.
Kathy obviously consulted with a Pilates pro for this video and she does a good job instructing. However, even though I forgive Kathy's tendency to stumble on her words in the higher intensity workouts in Project: YOU, this became rather irritating during Pilates. Perhaps because the instruction is non-stop?
Okay, so I will start out by saying I have never done Pilates before in my life. My second disclaimer is that I have two kids and lower ab muscles that obviously never recovered. LOL Otherwise I would say I'm an intermediate level exerciser in decent shape.
So on to my review. This workout takes you through a series of Pilates moves. I haven't done it in a week but some that come to mind (and I may murder these names) are hundreds, roll ups, swimmers, leg circles, and many others.
To me this workout seemed completely out of balance with the Foundations workout. Foundations IMO is just what the name implies, a beginners foundation workout. I felt that the Pilates workout on the other hand needed more instruction and modifiers for those that were completely clueless (ME!).
There are two or three moves that I couldn't complete, two of them being part of the beginning three moves. (This is where I learned about my shot lower abs.) Not a great way to start a workout. I had to go to the website to get suggestions on how to work myself up to the point where I could do the moves. Not very encouraging.
My suggestion to people with no Pilates experience is to do a beginners tape like Pilates for Dummies a few times before attempting this one.
Kathy Smith is an encouraging and enthusiastic instructor that I enjoy.
This is the intermediate cardio workout in the Project You set from Beachbody. I have already reviewed most of the other titles in this set. My general comments so far have been positive. I have a good track record with Beachbody products and was certain I would like this one.
Pilates Core is a 20-minute add-on workout meant to be paired with Yoga Flex, which I positively reviewed earlier. I will be a bit less effusive in this review :) But fair disclaimer, I don't love Pilates in general and am probably not completely qualified to comment here :)
That said, this seemed okay as far as these things go. About half of it is what I would consider Pilates to be from my past experience: 100's, single leg stretch, double leg stretch etc. The other half of it is more general core work such as planks and tabletop with bridges and some stretches. I liked having the two distinct sections like that, and I liked not having to do the icky stuff for the whole thing :)
I would say this is definately beginner level Pilates and an advanced person will not like it much. Kathy gives a form talk at the beginning, and there are rests after each little exercise. She is also much more interactive with the background crew in this one, going around and correcting individual form issues with them.
Final verdict? If I ever do feel like doing Pilates, this will be as viable a choice for me as any that I own. It seemed fine as far as these things go, I like Kathy, I like the short length. I just don't do Pilates very often though :)